One Font to Rule Them All (Well … almost)
In my past life I used to be an artist. According to my Mother (God rest her soul), I started drawing when I learned how to hold a pencil! I wanted to be a comic book artist and even took that track in university. In the drawing class, Friday’s used to be “free day,” meaning we could draw whatever we wanted. We would present our drawings to the class and our classmates would critique our work. I always drew comic book characters. I remember one day in particular when I put up my piece, some of my classmates moaned. Then they went on to talk about how “stupid” and “childish” it was to draw comic books. My instructor, however, came to my defense. “If he continues with this,” he responded, “he’ll make more money in a year than most of you will see in your lifetime. Now, critique his work, not offer your opinions about the subject matter. If you’ve got nothing to say, keep your comments to yourself.” Needless to say, I felt pretty good about myself. No one had a snarky thing to say about my work from that point on. Not in class, anyway.
However, that dream never came to fruition. Maybe I just didn’t have the patience or the grit to keep at it, but I never became a comic book artist. In fact, I haven’t really done much artwork for ages now.[1]
But that doesn’t mean I’ve given up on creativity. No. I turned to writing. I’ve written some fictitious short stories for people explaining theology. Plus I’ve contributed to two different published works with more on the way.[2] And I’m (still) working on my own book. Lastly, obviously, there’s this blog.
All of that to say, when it comes to writing, I look at the page — whether printer or digital — with an artist’s eye. And the presentation is really important to me; especifically the fonts. I remember I sent a copy of part of my book to a friend who happens to be an editor and he said, “Quit formatting the look of the page! Just finish the book already!”
But I can’t do that. Even in writing this blog the presentation has to look pleasant. And if it can’t look pleasant then it should look presentable, in the very least!
So a number of years ago I started a quest for a good — no, make that great — serif font. For those of us who may not know what that means, “serif” fonts have the little extras at the end of the letter (think Times New Roman). And “sans serif” fonts are the ones without that extra bit (think Arial). A non-negotiable point was the font had to have Open Source License. That means, the font had to be free to access, use, and distribute.
Through my research I located the Gentium font. It checked all the right boxes. When creating the font, Victor Gaultney looked to calligraphy for inspiration.[3] What he created is a beautiful font that flows more dynamically like a fountain pen than the static, uniformed letters of current popular fonts. Plus, it has a full character set for Greek and is one of the fonts recommended by Bill Mounce who teaches biblical Greek. If you ever see anything I control (like the liturgical pamphlets I create for services), the main font used will be Gentium.[4]
While Gentium is my favorite font, it’s not one of the font choices for the themes of my blog, so I have to select a different font. Below are the serif fonts available.[5]
Cambria:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Cardo:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Copse:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Crimson Text:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
EB Garamond:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
GFS Didot:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
IM Fell DW Pica:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
IM Fell English:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
IM Fell Great Primer:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Lora:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Merriweather:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Neuton:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Playfair Display:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Sorts Mill Goudy:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Tinos:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Vollkorn:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
So, how do I decide?
Well, first off, let’s get rid of any font where the number one (1) looks like an uppercase “I”. I just can’t stand that.
Cambria:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Cardo:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Copse:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Crimson Text:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
EB Garamond:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
GFS Didot:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC;1234567890
IM Fell DW Pica:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
IM Fell English:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
IM Fell Great Primer:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Lora:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Merriweather:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Neuton:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Playfair Display:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Sorts Mill Goudy:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Tinos:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Vollkorn:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Next, let’s take out all the fonts whose uppercase “O” looks more oval than circular:
Cambria:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Cardo:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Copse:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Crimson Text:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
EB Garamond:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
GFS Didot:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC;1234567890
Lora:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Merriweather:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Neuton:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Playfair Display:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Tinos:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Then I get rid of the fonts where the capital “J” doesn’t go beyond the bottom line. It’s weird, I know, but I really like that look:
Cardo:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Crimson Text:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
EB Garamond:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Lora:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Neuton:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Tinos:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
That means I’m left with the following fonts:
Cardo:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Crimson Text:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
EB Garamond:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Neuton:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
All of these fonts are fine and any one of them would do. So, which do I pick? Well, I’ve seen Garamond around a lot. A. Lot. So, I’ll drop it just to be different and a little contrary. Besides, I don’t really like the way the upper case “T” looks.
Cardo:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Crimson Text:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
EB Garamond:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Neuton:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Next, while I do prefer the capital “J” of the Neuton font, I’ll drop it because, well, the font’s a little on the smaller side of the scale.
Cardo:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Crimson Text:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
Neuton:
In the Love of the Three in One, Br. Jack+, LC; 1234567890
So that just leaves me with Cardo and Crimson Text. Hmm …
Wait …
Haven’t I seen Cardo mentioned before?
Just a second …
Yep, I did. It was one of the fonts listed on Mounce’s site. It use the same Open Source Licence that Gentium uses. And, it was specifically designed for “classicists, biblical scholars, medievalists, and linguists.” So, it looks like I’ve found my replacement — Cardo!
While I still prefer Gentium, and will continue to use it whenever possible, I’ll stick with Cardo on my blog for now. You know, this might have been a lot easier if I had just compared the list of recommendations from Mounce and the fonts available for my blog; Cardo is the only one listed! Oh well. At least this was fun investigation.
Thank you for coming along with me.
~~~
In the Love of the Three in One,
Br. Jack+, LC
~~~
[1] The last thing I’ve done was art therapy for a Spiritual Direction class.
[2] The first one was Secular Monasticism: A Journey. This is a book from the Lindisfarne Community where I’m a professed member and an ordained priest. The second book is The Winged Man: The Good News According to Matthew; the first volume of the Celtic Bible Commentary series.
[5] The problem is the fonts compared above may not display properly since I’ve selected the default font.
Comments